Tuesday, June 21, 2016

Review -- Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli Pirates: The Forgotten War That Changed American History

Before the United States won independence from Britain, pirates from the Barbary states (Morocco, Algiers, Tunis, and Tripoli) had a long history of depradations in the Mediterranean, beginning as far back as the era of the Crusades. In the sixteenth century, upon becoming part of the powerful Ottoman Empire, they expanded into the Atlantic, raiding not only shipping but even European coastal towns as far north as Iceland. Plunder was not their greatest prize; more than anything, they sought captives, some to hold for ransom but most to sell into slavery in the Ottoman and Arab worlds. It is estimated that over one million Europeans were thus enslaved, some doomed to wretched lives as labourers, perhaps manning the oars of a pirate galley, some kept as house slaves, a lucky few given positions as high-level officials, women, and especially young boys, kept as sex slaves. The European powers never subdued the pirates or their political masters militarily, apparently finding it preferable to make annual “tribute” payments as well as putting up with periodic demands for luxury gifts, such as diamond-studded daggers and gold-inlaid pistols, by the various beys and pashaws.

At the end of the War of Independence in 1783, the U.S. lost its protection under Britain`s deal with the Barbary states, and soon several American merchant ships were captured. The Americans on board were enslaved, chained, and set to work breaking rocks. Several died.

The U.S. was not in a position to do much. It had sold off its Continental Navy, and its treasury was so depleted that tribute payments to pirate nations were almost beyond its capacity. Yet it needed to keep its trade with Europe and the Mediterranean free in order to pay off its war debts. In 1786 Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, then ambassadors to France and Britain respectively, met in London with the ambassador from Tripoli to Britain, hoping to negotiate a reasonable settlement that would free American captives and protect American shipping. Instead, they were met with demands for tribute payments of enormous proportions. And, what shocked them even more, the ambassador blithely told them that the Quran made it a right and a duty for Muslims to plunder and enslave unbelievers. By 1793 ten American merchant ships had been captured and hundreds of American citizens were imprisoned. The pirates built a new fleet aimed specifically at American shipping.

Although it took thirty years of effort, both diplomatic and military, the young U.S. finally achieved what no other nation had done, ending Barbary piracy through military force, although not without some serious setbacks. Today the First and Second Barbary Wars are mostly forgotten, the memory kept alive mainly by the U.S. Marine Corps in a song memorializing their first victory on land (“From the halls of Montezuma to the shores of Tripoli”) and in their ceremonial sword, which is fashioned after the Ottoman-style, Mameluke sword presented to the Marine commander who won that battle.

Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli Pirates is a vivid account the Barbary wars, well researched from original sources, detailed enough to satisfy ordinary curiosity but with no unnecessary digressions, always keeping its focus on action and narrative. The big surprise of the story is how badly the effort went for the U.S. for so long, the number of mistakes, defeats, and humiliations. Interesting characters appear amid all the action. Remarkable for his lack of heroism is the American naval commander, Richard Morris, sent with the U.S.S. Chesapeake to blockade Tripoli. His wife wrote to the secretary of the navy for permission to accompany her husband on the mission and before the day of departure showed up with their son, too. Morris delayed his departure a month or two to avoid the rough weather of early spring. Arriving at Gibraltar for repairs, he delayed for three more months while he and Mrs. Morris enjoyed the local social life, hobnobbing with the British elite. Finally under direct orders to join the blockade immediately, he sailed out of Gibraltar but only to visit friendly ports along the southern European coast. In the first report he gave of his progress, he explained that he did not plan to advance toward North Africa until early in the following year because of the “advanced period of the season.” Not long afterward, he was relieved of duty. There is also the renegade Scotsman Peter Lisle who, after being captured, converted to Islam, took the name Murat Rais, and became captain of a pirate ship. Eventually he was promoted to admiral of Tripoli’s navy, and he married a daughter of the dey of Tripoli. Thomas Jefferson and John Adams presented a stark contrast. Adams always advocated negotiating with the pirate nations, even after the dey of Tripoli declared war. During his term as president he reduced the size of the navy. Early on Thomas Jefferson, on the other hand, decided that force would be necessary to bring the pirates to heel, and throughout his career as ambassador, secretary of defense, and as president, he sought to expand the navy and gain the authority to use military force.

One of the most shocking incidents occurred when an American ship, arriving with tribute in Algiers, was found not to have all the promised goods. Infuriated, the dey took control of the ship, replaced the American flag with his own, and forced the American crew to sail to Istanbul with the tribute he owed to the Ottoman emperor. Since slaves were part of his cargo, an American naval ship suffered the humiliation, not just of serving as an Ottoman cargo ship but of working as a slave transport.


After several military engagements, not all of which redounded to American glory, treaties were signed with all four Barbary nations. Then, during the War of 1812 Britain urged them to capture American ships again and take captives, and Algiers declared war on America. When the war with Britain ended in 1815, a much stronger U.S. sent a formidable fleet of eleven warships to the North African ports as gunboat diplomacy, and the era of Barbary piracy came to a quick end.

No comments:

Post a Comment